4

What is our stance on questions "is it safe to do X with medical condition Y"? Are they on-topic or off-topic?

Example:

Title: Is it safe to drive with a torn acl?

Last week, I tore my ACL (complete tear). Since then I've progressed from being immobilised / limited to crunches to being able to walk around with the support of a knee brace.

I do not have the full range of motion - my leg only bends a bit more than 90 degrees - and there is some instability, i.e. walking up and down stairs is uncomfortable.

I'm wondering if it is safe to drive.

1

Theoretically, it depends on the actual question, but I think that in most cases it constitutes personal medical advice - since many conditions can be presented in various forms and/or various degrees of severity, so a physician would need to assess all the factors and decide what is safe and what isn't for each individual patient.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .